Dale Ralph Davis on Jeroboam (in 1 Kings) making two bulls to substitute for Yahweh worship. Davis' concern is that some Bible commentators excuse Jeroboam, by claiming that later 'editors' have altered the original text. This is something Davis will not have - here, nor anywhere else. In a strongly-worded footnote (not the first one in this book) he writes:
'The problem with my view is that I have taken the testimony of the text at face value. Obviously, this is not good, furrow-browed scholarship. Many would hold that i fail to understand that the viewpoint in the text comes from later Judean editors who held an extremely anti-Jeroboam bias - hence one cannot depend on such texts. I don't mind if they think such. If they do, they should be faithful agnostics, i.e., they should deny that they can know anything accurate about Jeroboam's cult since the evidence is tainted. This they do not do; they deny the reliability of the texts yet proceed to do plastic surgery on Jeroboam. If the texts are unreliable, they should shut up. Instead they proceed to reconstruction based upon (essentially) re-written texts. This yields both bad history and perverse theology.' (page 139)
Davis isn't consistently opposed to certain commentators: Ian Provan, who is criticized in an earlier footnote or two, gets a thumbs up in a footnote just prior to the one quoted; Brueggemann, however, seldom comes off with commendations.
Showing posts with label brueggemann. Show all posts
Showing posts with label brueggemann. Show all posts
Sunday, August 19, 2018
Friday, January 16, 2015
Sabbath is not simply a pause
Sabbath is not simply a pause. It is an occasion for reimagining all of social life away from coercion and competition to compassionate solidarity. Such solidarity is imaginable and capable of performance only when the drivenness and acquisitiveness is broken. Sabbath is not simply the pause that refreshes. It is the pause that transforms. Whereas Israelites are always tempted to acquisitiveness, Sabbath is an invitation to receptivity, an acknowledgement that what is needed is given and need not be seized.
Walter Brueggemann
Sabbath as Resistance
Sabbath as Resistance
Thursday, May 09, 2013
Personal and public
Jesus in his solidarity with the marginal ones is moved to
compassion.... the compassion of Jesus is to be understood not simply
as a personal emotional reaction but as a public criticism in which he dares
to act upon his concern against the entire numbness of his social context.
Empires live by numbness. Empires, in their militarism, expect numbness
about the human cost of war. Corporate economies expect blindness to the
cost in terms of poverty and exploitation. Governments and societies of
domination go to great lengths to keep the numbness intact. Jesus penetrates
the numbness by his compassion and with his compassion takes the first step
by making visible the odd abnormality that had become business as usual.
Walter BrueggemannThe Prophetic Imagination
Walter BrueggemannThe Prophetic Imagination
Thursday, January 03, 2013
Prophetic crisis
We are, for the most part, double-minded. There is hidden deep within most of us, I suspect, a profound tension between these narratives, knowing better than to trust the dominant narrative but having a huge stake in its being true, wanting the gospel narrative to be true but reluctant to speak another language about the world other than the one in which we are palpably invested.... Prophetic preaching does not put people in crisis. Rather it names and makes palpable the crisis already pulsing among us. It is for that reason that we have such energy for resistance and denial. The hard work of adjudicating between these narratives is itself energizing. The hard work, in fact, is to keep the tension hidden, work that keeps us exhausted.
Walter Brueggemann
Monday, September 13, 2010
The prophetic voice

The essential question for the church is whether or not its prophetic voice has been co-opted into the culture of the day. The community of God's people who are striving to remain faithful to the whole counsel of God's Word will be prophetic voices crying out in the wilderness of the dominant culture of our day.
Walter Brueggemann
The Prophetic Imagination
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)